The Gateway Doctor

Posted on: April 9th, 2009 by

My grandmother always told me, “If you have your health, you have everything.” As a child, I didn’t understand the truth in these words. I didn’t heed these words as a healthy young adult: I came from very genetically healthy stock — people in my family die of old age for goodness sakes, even the ones exposed to asbestos, lead, and various other toxins!

I didn’t heed my grandma’s words until I was diagnosed with breast cancer. Because let’s face it: I, as so many people, took my health for granted — until I didn’t have it.

Now I’m going to spin my grandma’s words to suit my medical-advocacy purpose: “If you have a great gateway doctor, you have everything.”

Besides you, the most important person managing your health care is the “gateway doctor,” also known as the primary care physician, internist, general family doctor, etc. Whether or not you are healthy, whether or not your family has had the same physician they have felt comfortable with for decades, whether or not your doctor is well-versed in all of the new medical technologies, whether or not your doctor has had an established practice with a good reputation, it all boils down to this:

Do you trust your family doctor with your life?

If the answer is anything but a resounding, enthusiastic “YES!,” find another doctor immediately. Your life is too precious to take a chance with incompetence and mediocrity.

I measure competent doctors by their medical and emotional know-how. They must be medically competent (sounds like I’m stating the obvious, but it needs to be stated) and they must have your best interest at heart. The latter point means more than just bedside manner: I have had doctors be pleasant to me during an examination, but mere pleasantries are not enough.

You must LOVE your doctor.

As is the case with specialists, the ideal gateway doctor cares about you as a patient and will work as hard as possible to advocate for you. Another perk is that a great family-practice physician tends to keep company with other excellent doctors — and that opens the gateway to outstanding medical care.

I was lucky to have an outstanding gateway doctor in place before I got diagnosed with breast cancer. She was my physician for years because we had great patient-doctor chemistry.

Let me tell you what she did for me during my breast cancer journey:

She called me often, coaching me through the diagnosis and prognosis. She listened to me, and validated my concerns. She encouraged questions and provided prompt answers. She returned my phone calls, often on the same day that I left her a message. And she was working behind the scenes and putting an excellent team in place for me. She landed a great surgeon, steered me toward a fantastic medical oncologist and radiation oncologist. These top-level professionals all worked tirelessly to save my life, but they didn’t treat me as if I were a mere patient.

They treated me like family.

And they were all HMO doctors.

(In a future blog, I will dispel the myth that all HMO doctors are bad.)

And even though I had a medical team of specialists who were unbelievably outstanding and kind — like off-the-charts brilliant and sweet people — I probably wouldn’t have crossed paths with them, had it not been for my gateway doctor, whom I have called my guardian angel.

So now that I’ve waxed poetic about my gateway doctor, here are some litmus tests that can help you find the doctor that’s right for you. These tests also apply to specialists, but you need a great PCP in place before you can even consider a specialist.

You’ll need to set up a routine exam, perhaps with several doctors, to find the right one so please be patient.

Litmus test one: During your meeting, give an emotional prompt, like: “I’m afraid of blood tests.” Observe the doctor’s reactions. Is he/she emotionally vested in you? Reassuring? If not, find another doctor.

Litmus test two: Sometime in the week following your exam, call the doctor to ask a question. Does the doctor call you back promptly? Does he or she communicate with you clearly and patiently? Does he or she take your concerns seriously? If the answer to any of these is “no,” find another doctor.

Litmus test three: Based on litmus tests one and two, do you LOVE your doctor? If you are feeling badly about him/her or just so-so, find another doctor. Don’t settle for mediocrity because if there were a medical crisis, a doctor you love and who cares deeply about your welfare will be the one who fights for you.

Litmus test four: Does the doctor play “ring around the patient,” where he/she continuously throws statistics to impress you with his or her know-how? Does he/she come with print-outs of pages from the Internet to illustrate these statistics? Do you feel confused during and/or after the session?

Run – do not walk – away from this doctor.

Litmus test five: Does the doctor use scare tactics, telling you all the terrible things that can happen to you? Is he/she dismissive of your emotional and physical needs? Does he or she sound like a doctor who has watched too many ER or Grey’s Anatomy episodes? If so, this is not the doctor for you.

All in all, trust your instincts and be persistent in your goals to find a great doctor. You will know whether a doctor is a good fit for you. Also, if you suspect something is wrong and a doctor does not give you a satisfactory answer or solution, then continue advocating for yourself. Don’t accept answers like, “You are too young to get cancer.”

Demand to be treated with respect and, if need be, be difficult to those who treat you unfairly. You have an amazing power to demand to be treated with respect – whether from doctors, nurses, and office personnel. If someone treats you with disrespect, such as rudeness, talk back.

You are nobody’s doormat, and they need to know it.


This blog posting is an excerpt from my book in progress, Calling the Shots: Coaching Yourself Through the Medical System. Stay in loop for when it comes out. Subscribe to the blog in upper righthand corner.

6 Responses to The Gateway Doctor

  1. Jeannie had this to say about that:

    Another excellent post, Beth. I read through your tests and am thankful for the reassurance that I have a great doctor (not that I ever doubted it, but you’re right, we should scrutinze our doctors to be sure they still measure up to quality care.)

  2. Beth L. Gainer had this to say about that:

    Thanks, Jeannie!! The Litmus tests are also great for reassuring ourselves that our current doctors rock!! It’s great you have a wonderful doctor.

  3. Sandi had this to say about that:

    I like my family doc but I can’t say I love him. I think he’s alright. The office here is just ok by my standards. I mean they are all nice and it’s a small town so everyone knows everyone. I just am not sure if I’d go so far as trusting them with my life….even if there intentions are good. I really wish I had that. I will say however my oncologist and that whole office is AMAZING. They are just awesome and I am so glad that I found them. They fought for my life and my baby’s life.

  4. Beth L. Gainer had this to say about that:


    Thank you for your response. It is great that your oncologist and the whole office staff were so caring to fight for both of your lives.

    You have been through a harrowing experience, and I admire your courage and fortitude.

  5. Helene had this to say about that:

    Thanks for your contribution to Take Charge of Your Health Care Carnival. You have given my readers some good guidelines in what to look for in a primary care physician.

  6. Beth L. Gainer had this to say about that:

    Thank you for including my posting in the Take Charge of Your Health Care Carnival, Helene! I really appreciate it.

Add Your Comment, Feedback or Opinion Here

Your email is safe here. It will not be published or shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>